Viremic controllers (VC) are individuals who maintain low viral loads without anti-retroviral therapy and are considered models of functional cure. Characterizing the mechanisms that lead to the natural control of HIV-1 is needed to better understand and inform cure strategies. In this study, we analyze an HIV-1 transmission pair, where a chronic progressor (TP5M) transmitted HIV-1 to a recipient who became a VC (TP5F).
We sequenced replication competent virus to assess genome integrity. Virus replication was tested in-vitro by a growth kinetics assay utilizing a p24 ELISA. In-vivo replication was assessed by infecting CD4 T cell engrafted Nod SCID Gamma humanized mice. Further, the ability of viruses to downregulate HLA-A2 and CD4 in infected cells was assessed by flow cytometry.
The chronic progressor (TP5M) had a CD4 count of 76 cells/uL and a viral load of 673,000 copies/mL, while the VC (TP5F) had a CD4 count of 964 cells/ul and a viral load of 62 copies/ml. Neither patient had protective HLA alleles. Replication-competent isolates from both subjects were obtained with a viral outgrowth assay. The isolate from TP5M replicated slightly better than an isolate from TP5F with p24 concentrations of 1441 ng/ml versus 655 ng/ml at day 10 compared to 44 ng/ml versus 23 ng/ml at day 0. The viral isolate from TP5M replicated better than the isolate from TP5F in humanized mice with viral loads of 1.4e8 and 3.7e6 copies/ml versus 9.6e6 and 2.5e4 copies/ml respectively at 7 days post-infection. Sequencing of LTR, gag, pol, integrase and the accessory genes confirmed that TP5F and TPF5M were a transmission pair. All four TP5F replication-competent viral isolates had numerous mutations and deletions in nef, including a 16 base pair deletion that resulted in a frame shift and premature stop codon. These mutations affected nef function as primary CD4+ T cells infected with TP5F virus had 2-to-4-fold lower downregulation of CD4 and HLA-A2 (mean fluorescence intensity [MFI] of 9664 and 3083) compared to TP5M virus infected cells (MFI of 3634 and 782 respectively).
Together, these data suggest that unlike TP5M, TP5F viral isolates are attenuated due to non-functional nef. This attenuation probably contributed to the natural control of viral replication in TP5F. Our data suggests that transmission of attenuated minor variants can explain discordant outcomes in some transmission pairs.