Background: Simeprevir plus sofosbuvir (with or without ribavirin) (SMV/SOF) increases rates of sustained virologic response (SVR) over telaprevir- or boceprevir-based triple therapy (TT) (89-100% vs 64- 75%). Our objective was to examine the total treatment cost and cost per SVR of SMV/SOF versus TT.
Methods: Patients were included if they had chronic hepatitis C, were infected with HCV genotype 1, and had been prescribed either SMV/SOF or TT between May 1, 2011 – August 1, 2014. Transplant recipients and HIV co-infected patients were excluded. Electronic medical records were used to collect data on: demographics, duration of HCV treatment, virologic response, clinic visits for treatment monitoring, HCV-related emergency room visits, and hospitalizations, treatment related blood transfusions, management of hematologic side effects by medications (epoetin alfa, filgrastim) and outpatient laboratory monitoring (estimated per clinic-defined treatment protocol). Unit costs for all medical services and labs were obtained from a national claims database IMS Lifelink with 8 million covered lives. HCV drug treatment costs were obtained from RED Book. SVR rates were defined by undetectable HCV RNA at 12 weeks (SVR12) for TT and at 4 weeks (SVR4) for SMV/SOF after end of treatment. Cost per SVR was calculated by dividing the mean total cost by the SVR rate.
Results: There were 118 patients in the TT group (mean age = 53) vs 39 patients (mean age = 59) in the SMV/SOF group. Majority were male (54% in TT vs 59% in SMV/SOF) and Caucasian (86% in TT vs 94% in SMV/SOF). The SMV/SOF group had more advanced fibrosis (72% vs 57%), more treatment-experienced patients (64% vs 54%), and improved tolerability than TT. More TT patients (44% vs 0%) discontinued therapy for toxicity or virologic failure. An SVR4 rate of 87% was achieved in the SMV/SOF vs an SVR12 rate of 62% in the TT group. The cost per SVR4 in SMV/SOF group was $187,365 vs cost per SVR12 of $150,584 in the TT group. Majority of the costs in both groups were HCV drug costs, however HCV-related medical costs (outpatient, emergency room, and inpatient visits, laboratory monitoring, and hematologic side effect management) were 6 times higher in the TT group ($12,962 per patient) vs SMV/SOF ($2,279 per patient) (Table 1).
Conclusions: This interim analysis shows SMV/SOF has more favorable efficacy and tolerability especially in more difficult-to-treat patients with HCV genotype 1 infection, but is associated with higher medication costs and cost per SVR.