Background: HIV-1 vaccines need to elicit neutralizing antibodies (nabs) that target conserved Env epitopes to protect against diverse HIV-1. To achieve this, we need to increase our knowledge on how different amino acids affect Env trimer structure. Native Env trimers are likely to be closed to protect against nabs and only triggered to open by CD4. Our hypothesis is that tightly closed trimers will (1) hide immunodominant non-neutralizing or strain specific Env sites e.g. V3 loop, and (2) expose conserved epitopes e.g. on the trimer association domain. To identify Env residues that maintain a closed trimer, we used EMPIRIC (Exceedingly Meticulous and Parallel Investigation of Randomized Individual Codons) saturation mutagenesis. We created a library of viruses carrying every possible amino acid in an Env region downstream from the CD4 binding loop. Following fitness competition in PBMCs in the absence of immune pressure, we identified several mutations that facilitate trimer opening.
Methods: We used EMPIRIC saturation mutagenesis to create a plasmid library containing all possible mutations for aa 371-380 of LN40 Env in NL4-3 full length virus. We recovered viruses from transfected 293T cells and then infected PBMCs. To quantify competitive fitness, we measured the abundance of each mutant before and after PBMC infection using deep sequencing. We then studied 14 mutations that were selected at wt levels or higher in PBMCs. We evaluated changes in Env structure by testing the sensitivity of Env+ pseudovirions to neutralization by sCD4 and mabs b6, b12, 447-52D and 2G12.
Results: Substitutions at aa380 conferred sensitivity to CD4bs mab, b6 and V3 mab, 447-52D, which recognize more open trimers e.g. on laboratory strains. Substitutions at aa373, 375 in addition to 380 increased sensitivity to sCD4 compared to wt. Several substitutions conferred increased sensitivity to the CD4bs mab b12, with changes in residues 373 and 375 affecting b12, sCD4, 447-52D and 2G12 sensitivity together. Our data indicate that the residues identified play an important role in enhancing CD4 binding and/or regulating trimer opening.
Conclusions: We identified specific amino acids in a region of Env proximal to the CD4 binding loop that facilitate trimer opening, increasing the exposure of neutralizing epitopes and sensitivity to sCD4. The identification of specific positions in gp120 that affect trimer opening will help the design of stably closed trimers for use in vaccines.