HIV incidence remains high among adolescent girls and young women (AGYW) in Zimbabwe. Tenofovir-based oral pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) can prevent individual infection, but population level impact and disaggregation of the direct (primary) and indirect (secondary/onward) preventive effects remain unexplored for this population. We assessed potential population-level benefits of oral PrEP use among female sex workers (FSW) and AGYW, and parse direct from indirect effects.
An individual-based HIV network model, EMOD-HIV v2.5, was parameterized for Zimbabwe to simulate provincial-level epidemics. The model was fit to age/gender/province-specific data on HIV prevalence and treatment coverage from DHS and Zimbabwe MoHCC reports. In the simulation, oral PrEP was provided to FSW and/or AGYW (18-24 years) with multiple partners at 40% coverage beginning in 2017 with a 5-year regimen of 73% effectiveness, which represents 90% efficacy with 81% adherence. Direct and indirect infections averted by oral PrEP were estimated by simulating a randomized trial (RT) in which 40% of the target population received oral PrEP and 40% received placebo drug. Direct prevention was computed from the incidence rate ratio between the two arms. Indirect prevention was computed as the difference between the number of HIV infections in the RT simulation and the number of HIV infections in a separate PrEP-free counterfactual simulation.
For every infection directly averted by providing oral PrEP to FSW, 1.3 additional infections were indirectly averted in the community over 5 years and 1.7 additional infections were prevented in 20 years. The ratios were 1 and 1.7 when targeting only AGYW with multiple partners over the same horizons. Total numbers of indirect infections averted by oral PrEP increased in all ten provinces when providing PrEP to both FSW and AGYW, compared to the scenario of providing oral PrEP to FSW alone. In this scenario, the ratio of indirect to direct infections averted was 0.9 over 5 years and 1.8 over 20 years.
Results suggest that community benefit of oral PrEP can outweigh direct individual-level benefit. Indirect benefits of PrEP should be considered when prioritizing populations for PrEP service provision.