Oral pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) is highly effective for HIV prevention in men who have sex with men (MSM). To address challenges associated with daily pill adherence, injectable formulations are being tested in phase III trials. Long-acting cabotegravir (LA-CAB), an integrase strand transfer inhibitor, was demonstrated to have a strong protective effect in animal models. We used an agent-based model (ABM) to estimate the effectiveness of LA-CAB compared to oral PrEP on HIV incidence among MSM.
The ABM simulated HIV transmission in a dynamic sexual network of 11,000 MSM in Atlanta, Georgia over a 10-year time period (2015-2025). The model was calibrated to reproduce current HIV prevalence and incidence among MSM in Atlanta (30.3% and 3.9 per 100 person-years). We assumed agents received bimonthly LA-CAB bimonthly injections, with retention rates based on phase II trial data. The theoretical efficacy of LA-CAB was estimated from published macaque data using logistic regression, with waning protection up to 12 months following a final injection. LA-CAB concentrations over time were estimated from human pharmacokinetic data. The impact of LA-CAB on HIV incidence compared to oral PrEP was investigated across different PrEP target coverage levels. Sensitivity analyses investigated varied efficacies, retention rates, and half-lifes of LA-CAB.
We estimated a theoretical efficacy of >99% among agents receiving bimonthly LA-CAB injections. Over the 10-year simulation period, HIV incidence was reduced in scenarios in which agents received LA-CAB compared to scenarios in which all received oral PrEP, at every coverage level (Figure). For example, a scenario in which 35% of HIV-uninfected agents receive LA-CAB averted an additional 255 infections over the next decade compared to a scenario in which 35% receive oral PrEP. The relative benefit of LA-CAB was sensitive to the maximum efficacy of bi-monthly LA-CAB injections and the terminal half-life after a final injection. For any given coverage level, decreasing the LA-CAB retention rate increased relative the benefit of the injectable formulation, due to a greater pool of agents with partial protection.
Long-acting PrEP may be more effective than oral PrEP for preventing HIV acquisition in MSM. However, the population impact and relative benefit of LA-PrEP will depend on the efficacy observed in ongoing phase III trials, as well as the extent and duration of protection among persons who drop out of LA-PrEP care.