HIV-1 polymerase (pol) sequences from routine HIV drug resistance (DR) testing are used to monitor DR and identify molecular transmission clusters as part of public health (PH) surveillance. Proviral DNA DR testing using next-generation sequencing (DNA-NGS) has been used clinically since 2015 to provide DR information in the setting of viral suppression. Since DNA-NGS covers the same part of the HIV genome and DNA-NGS consensus sequences mimic traditional RNA-Sanger (RNA-S) sequences, they have likely been reported to PH as RNA-S sequences. Some clinical labs are also using (and others are considering) NGS for RNA-based DR testing (RNA-NGS). We evaluated whether shifts in testing methods and sequencing technology have implications for PH surveillance of DR and transmission clusters.
We identified ~115,000 RNA-S, ~11,000 DNA-NGS, and ~5,000 RNA-NGS sequences reported to New York during 2010-2019 from a single commercial lab. Inferred DR was compared for 1,350 persons with two or more sequence types. For cluster analyses, pairwise genetic distances were calculated between sequences for the same person with collection dates within 1 year (n=7,771 comparisons from 2,823 individuals) using Secure HIV-TRACE default settings and a 2% genetic distance threshold, stratified by sequence type.
Overall, DR was 37% more likely to be inferred from DNA-NGS sequences than RNA-based sequences from the same individual. Time between tests was not a significant factor, and individual drug classes showed similar results. For clustering, over 25% of DNA-NGS were rejected by Secure HIV-TRACE due to high levels of ambiguities compared to RNA-NGS (11%) and RNA-S (8%). Based on pairwise distances for sequences from the same individual, RNA-NGS and especially DNA-NGS sequences, clustered less frequently than RNA-S sequences and at a higher distance threshold if they did cluster. Mean number of years since diagnosis was high and varied by sequence types but did not explain the results (Table 1).
We found significant differences between consensus DNA-NGS and RNA-NGS sequences compared to RNA-S sequences for cluster inference and between DNA-NGS and RNA-based sequences for DR. Hence, reporting of sequence type for PH surveillance is critical for ensuring appropriate inclusion of sequences for accurate HIV DR and transmission cluster analyses. Monitoring changes in sequencing technology is critical for assessing impact on PH and clinical decisions.