HIV post-treatment controllers (PTCs) serve as models for sustained HIV remission. These individuals frequently have early HIV rebound before viral control and subsequent periods of intermittent low-level viremia. Little is known about the viral composition during these periods of viremia.
We extracted longitudinal plasma HIV RNA from PTCs and post-treatment non-controllers (NCs) from AIDS Clinical Trials Group (ACTG) analytic treatment interruption (ATI) trials. Single-genome sequences (SGSs) of HIV-1 pol were obtained at pre- and multiple post-ATI time points (median 90 wks at the late time point for the PTCs). Sequence analysis included calculations of viral genetic diversity by average pairwise distance (APD), root-to-tip distances, percent of HLA-escape mutations, and panmixia testing.
Despite low plasma viremia, >1200 SGSs were obtained for 20 PTCs and 13 NCs. Early after ATI, chronic-treated NCs had the highest levels of plasma HIV diversity while viral diversity was limited for both early-treated PTCs and NCs. Over time, increasing viral diversity was detected in almost all PTCs, but rates of diversification were significantly slower in PTCs compared to NCs (median 0.05% vs 0.27% per year, p=0.007). PTCs were also able to maintain viral control despite evidence of viral evolution. This included increasing root-to-tip distances of HIV sequences by phylogenetic analysis over time for all PTCs, divergent population structures by the panmixia test in 73% of PTCs, and accumulation of HLA escape mutations in longitudinal sampling for 2 chronic-treated PTCs (Figure). The proportion of HLA-escape mutations were common in plasma HIV sequences from PTCs and not significantly different than NCs (47% vs 59%, p=0.16). Unexpectedly, the presence of dual HIV infections (populations of HIV variants with ≥5% sequence divergence) was detected in the plasma SGSs for 3 PTCs (1 early-treated, 2 chronic-treated) and for none of the NCs. In two participants, dual infection was detected at the early ATI time point with one variant becoming dominant over time. One individual was found to have an apparent superinfection with a late post-ATI viral rebound of a second HIV variant before subsequently regaining HIV control.
PTCs exhibit sustained HIV remission despite evidence of slow plasma viral diversification and evolution. The detection of dual HIV infection in a subset of PTCs suggests the presence of an antiviral response that can control a diverse viral population.