A small number of HIV-infected individuals are able to effectively suppress HIV replication without antiretroviral therapy. Certain ‘protective’ HLA types correlate with this ability to suppress HIV replication, indicating that the CD8+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response in these individuals is responsible for the efficient containment of HIV. However, the mechanism behind CTL mediated control is unclear and has been suggested to be a result of either increased ability of the CTLs to recognize escape mutants or due to the ability of protective HLA types to present conserved viral epitopes. In this project we define all possible single and double amino acid mutations that the HIV can assume to escape CTL targeting, and the effect of these mutations on relative viral fitness within two HIV-1 immunodominant epitopes: SL9 (Gag 77-85) and KF11 (Gag 162-172) presented by the non-protective HLA A*02 and the protective HLA B*5701, respectively.
Plasmid libraries encoding full length HIV with all possible single and double amino acid mutations within the SL9 and KF11 epitope were synthesized. Live virus was created from this library and passaged in HIV permissive cells in the absence or presence of epitope-specific CTLs. The passaged virus was deep sequenced to identify viable variants and variants that could escape CTL recognition.
48 variants within SL9 and 33 within KF11 maintained reasonable relative fitness. KF11 specific CTLs recognized 13-16 of these variants while SL9 specific CTLs recognized 7-24 variants. 2 KF11 and 11 SL9 variants were at least as fit as wild type. KF11 specific CTLs recognized all of these most fit variants, while SL9 specific CTLs recognized only 0-45% of the most fit variants.
CTLs targeting SL9 and KF11 do not differ in their ability to cross recognize escape variants. However, HIV is far less tolerant of mutations within KF11 than SL9, giving the virus fewer options for escape at this epitope. Furthermore, since KF11 specific CTLs can recognize all of the most fit KF11 variants (while SL9 specific CTLs cannot), HIV must sacrifice replicative capacity to escape CTL recognition of KF11. ,Our findings indicate that the beneficial effect of protective HLA types derives from the ability of these HLAs to present highly conserved regions of the virus, and from the ability of CTLs targeting these epitopes to cross recognize only the few fit variants that exist within such regions.