HIV spreads across sexual and injection drug-using partner networks, resulting in clusters of genetically similar viruses. The extent of this clustering is more often associated with risk behavior than viral traits (i.e., viral transmission fitness). Viral load (VL) is a viral trait associated with transmissibility and disease progression. We examined cases diagnosed at different stages of infection to test the hypothesis that VL is associated with transmission fitness (i.e., clustering) in a large U.S. transmission network.
We analyzed HIV-1 polymerase sequences from 24,028 persons from the U.S. National HIV Surveillance System who were genotyped < 3 months of HIV diagnosis during 2001–2016, received a VL measurement before or within 1 month of genotyping, were treatment-naïve at diagnosis, and had no drug resistance mutations. HIV-TRACE was used to construct a molecular transmission network. We used multiple linear regression analysis to assess the relationship between the log10 earliest VL measurement and clustering in 5,914 cases diagnosed at Stage 1 infection (CD4 cell count ≥500/µL). Birth sex, transmission risk factor, race/ethnicity, age at diagnosis, year of diagnosis, subtype, and CD4 count were included as covariates. Similar analysis was performed on cases diagnosed at Stage 2 (CD4 200–499/µL) and Stage 3 (CD4 <200/µL).
The 2,787 cases diagnosed at Stage 1 that clustered in the network had a mean VL of 70,745 copies/ml, 27% higher than the 3,127 unclustered cases (p < 0.001). This finding was robust to the timing of VL measurement, demographic/risk covariates, CD4 count, network structure, genetic distance threshold for assigning partner clustering (0.005 to 0.015 substitutions/site), and inclusion/exclusion of people who inject drugs. Larger clusters (≥5 vs. <5 and ≥10 vs. <10 persons) had increasingly higher VL in cases diagnosed at Stage 1 (p = 0.01). Similar patterns of higher VL in clustered cases were observed for those cases diagnosed at Stage 2 (27%; p < 0.001) and Stage 3 (7.5%; p = 0.003).
Circulating wild type viruses in a large transmission network differ in transmissibility. The robust association between VL and clustering reflects a heritable and durable viral trait maintained throughout infection stages. These findings heighten the importance of interrupting growing transmission clusters comprising cases with high VL through network-assisted targeting of public health interventions.