Anal cancer is a leading neoplasia in HIV-infected MSM. The current screening strategy is based on the detection of high-degree squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL), using anal cytology. While this approach shows good sensitivity, the specificity is poor. We aimed to identify in MSM a set of anal-associated bacterial biomarkers for the diagnosis of biopsy-proven HSIL (bHSIL).
Cross-sectional prospective study performed in HIV+ and HIV- MSM referred to a high-resolution anoscopy clinic. The primary outcome was the presence of bHSIL at the inclusion or during the previous year. We analyzed fecal and mucosal microbiota to search for biomarkers predictive of the presence of bHSIL. We collected fecal samples in specific containers and obtained anal mucosa specimens with an anal cytobrush. The V3-V4 region of the 16S rRNA gene was sequenced using the Illumina platform. We selected the biomarkers based on their LDA scores, AUC-ROC in logistic regression models and concomitant predictive value in feces.
We included 118 HIV+ and 33 HIV- MSM: 47 had bHSIL during the previous year and 12 at the moment of the inclusion. Differences in alpha and bacterial diversity were significant between mucosa and feces, but non-significant in the comparison by presence of bHSIL or HIV status. Linear discriminant analysis (LDA) effect size (LEfSe) revealed 40 biomarkers in mucosa and 53 in stools. After exploring the predictive value of the 15 taxa with greater LDA scores, we selected four taxa in anal samples. Each 25% increase in the abundance of the Ruminococcaceae NK4A214 group and Alloprevotella genus were associated with a 17% (p=0.041) and 8% (p=0.016) increased risk of bHSIL, respectively. The absence of Prevotella melanonigenica and Ruminococcaceae UCG-014 were predictive of bHSIL (OR 6.1, P=0.018 and OR 3.2, P=0.026, respectively). From 35 (94%) of false positive cytologic results, the combination of these four biomarkers reclassified to true negative 33 (94%), significantly improving the predictive performance of anal cytology alone to AUC 0.805.
We found anal-associated bacteria indicative of higher risk of precancerous anal lesions, which combination was highly specific. The microbiota could be exploited as a complementary diagnostic tool for anal cytology to overcome the low specificity and high rate of false positive results of the current screening strategy for anal cancer screening.