Several groups have proposed that genotypic determinants in HIV-1 gag matrix (MA) and the gp41 cytoplasmic domain (gp41-CD) cause PI resistance. However, MA and gp41-CD mutations selected by PI therapy have not been identified.
We sequenced PR, RT, complete gag and/or gp41 (codons 35-345) before and after therapy in 60 pts with VF on an initial PI (n=40) or NNRTI (n=20) regimen including 34 pts from ACTG A5202 and 26 California clinic pts. To detect selective evolutionary pressure on gag and gp41, we calculated the dn/ds ratios in these genes for each sequence pair. Additionally, each gag and gp41 amino acid was characterized by its prevalence in subtype B sequences from PI-naïve pts in the LANL HIV Sequence Database. We then identified mutations in our dataset at which conserved or relatively common amino acids changed to an amino acid that was >10-fold less prevalent and defined these as having a high selection index.
Of 40 pts with VF on an initial PI regimen, we sequenced gag + gp41 in 12 pts, gag alone in 12 pts, and gp41 alone in 16 pts. The median duration of PI therapy was 24.5 months. 36 received ATV/r and 4 received LPV/r. 37 pts attained plasma VL <100 copies/ml at some time during therapy. 3 developed PI DRMs and 10 developed NRTI DRMs. Of 20 pts with VF on an initial NNRTI regimen, we sequenced gag + gp41 in 13 pts, gag alone in 3 pts, and gp41 alone in 4 pts. There were no significant differences between the PI and NNRTI pts in the median number of gag (6 vs 6), gag-MA (4 vs 4), gp41 (4 vs 3), or gp41-CD (1 vs 3) mutations or in the gag dn/ds (0.14 vs 0.22), gag-MA dn/ds (0.20 vs. 0.39), gp41 dn/ds (0.27 vs 0.27), or gp41-CD dn/ds (0.36 vs. 0.30) ratios. In PI pts, there were 27 gag changes (12 in MA) with a high selection index including two in 2 pts: A115T and the P2/NC cleavage site mutation M378I. There were also 38 gp41 changes (27 in CD) with a high selection index including two in 2 pts: A268V and S293N. However, there was no significant difference in the number of highly selected gag, gag-MA, gp41, or gp41-CD changes between the PI and NNRTI pts.
There was no evidence for an overall difference in selective pressure in gag-MA or gp41-CD between patients receiving an initial PI or NNRTI regimen. The accumulation of additional sequences obtained before and after PI therapy will make it possible to determine whether individual gag-MA or gp41-CD mutations are selected by PIs.