Daily and on-demand pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) with oral TDF-FTC are effective at preventing HIV acquisition among men who have sex with men (MSM), but only daily PrEP is recommended in the US. However, on-demand PrEP, in which individuals align their pill-taking with sexual activity, may improve uptake and adherence. In this modeling study, we aim to identify sub-groups of MSM who would benefit from using on-demand PrEP and determine the potential overall effectiveness achieved if individuals were assigned to their optimal regimen.
We simulated a cross-over trial in a synthetic cohort of 10,000 MSM whose pill taking and sexual behavior parameters were calibrated to data from the Harlem site of the HPTN 067 trial. Individuals were assigned daily PrEP for 6 months, followed by on-demand PrEP for 6 months (2-1-1 regime, with 2 pills the day of sex and 1 pill on each of the following 2 days). For each individual, we determined and assigned optimal regimen and simulated the whole cohort for another 6 months. Daily PrEP was the optimal regime unless on-demand PrEP had: i) improved effectiveness with fewer pills taken than daily PrEP in the initial simulations; ii) >10 percentage points (pp) higher effectiveness than daily PrEP with at most twice the number of pills taken, or iii) <10 pp lower effectiveness than daily PrEP with fewer than half the number of pills taken.
On-demand PrEP was optimal and assigned mainly to MSM with low adherence to daily PrEP (62% of MSM in the lowest daily PrEP adherence quintile and only 5% of MSM in the highest). 78% of individuals for whom on-demand PrEP was optimal were from the lowest two daily PrEP adherence quintiles (panel A). The mean effectiveness for the full cohort when individuals used their optimal regimes was only 2 pp higher than universal daily PrEP use. However, for the subgroup for which on-demand PrEP was optimal (27% of the cohort), mean effectiveness was improved by 12 pp (panel B). There was little advantage to assigning on-demand PrEP by sex frequency, which was optimal for 28% and 25% of MSM in the lowest and highest sex frequency tertile, respectively.
On-demand PrEP could benefit many US MSM by increasing effectiveness or decreasing pill count with similar effectiveness. Most MSM for whom on-demand PrEP was optimal were in the lower daily adherence quintiles, indicating that on-demand PrEP should be offered to individuals with difficulty taking daily PrEP consistently.