Abstract Body

Background: Genetic analysis of HIV-1 sequences has become the gold standard for inferring HIV transmission networks. However, the added value of epidemiological links supplied via partner counseling and referral services (PCRS) is unclear.

Methods: We examined bulk pol sequence and epidemiological data from the San Diego Primary Infection Resource Consortium (PIRC) collected between 1996 and 2013. PCRS services were routinely provided to recently HIV infected persons to characterize epidemiologically linked partnerships (named partners). Two individuals whose nucleotide HIV-1 sequences differed by at most 1.5% (Tamura-Nei 93 distance) were considered genetically linked. We compared two types of putative transmission pairs: Group 1: genetically and epidemiologically linked, and Group 2: genetically, but not epidemiologically linked.

Results: 591 newly HIV infected persons were identified in the PIRC cohort. Provision of PCRS yielded 184 epidemiologically linked partnerships, of which 52 (28%) were also genetically linked (Group 1). Of the remaining 132 partnerships, 93 were linked to HIV-negative individuals and 39 (21% of total) were linked to HIV-infected persons whose genetic sequences differed. Sequence analysis alone identified 459 dyads (i.e. Group 2). 337 individuals made up the 511 pairs (Groups 1 + 2) included in this analysis. There were no significant differences comparing dyad concordance between Groups 1 and 2 with regard to race, ethnicity, income, CD4, viral load, and recent or current sexually transmitted infections. Partner age differences were greater in Group 2 (p = 0.012). The elapsed time between identification of the index and their linked partner was significantly different (p<0.001) between groups (Group 1 median 15 days [IQR 7-46 days]; Group 2 median 532.5 days [IQR 222-1194 days]).

Conclusions: Sequence analysis and PCRS may identify a uniquely different population than that identified with sequence analysis alone. As expected, only a minority (28%) of PCRS pairs were corroborated by genetic data, yet these partnerships yielded a more rapid linkage identification (15 days vs 532 days) and also captured individuals more similar in age, as compared to partnerships identified solely by genetic analysis. We conclude that the primary and valuable benefit of PCRS is to yield recently connected putative transmission pairs that may represent more attractive targets for interventions and are more likely to represent direct transmission events.