Background:
The error-prone nature of HIV-1 replication and host factors generate defective genomes. Defective proviruses persist, can be transcribed, and translated contributing to HIV-1 pathogenesis. During antiretroviral therapy (ART), most defective proviruses contain large deletions and hypermutations precluding the investigation of gene-specific selection pressures. We studied selection pressures on whole HIV-1 genomes and subgenomes of >7kb near-full length (NFL) defective proviruses prior to following ART.
Methods:
Blood cells were collected from 11 HIV-1 suppressed participants prior to and at multiple timepoints on ART (4-20 years). We performed single genome sequencing of >7kb proviruses and identified defective proviruses with stop codons, insertions/deletions or hypermutations. We collapsed identical sequences and compared the whole genomic and subgenomic characteristics of defective proviruses from pretherapy to ART. We predicted the Major Histocompatibility (MHC) class I binding, immunogenicity, and sensitivity to Broadly Neutralizing Antibodies (bNabs)
Results:
We obtained 705 NFL defective sequences. Proportions of hypermutant proviruses were not significantly different prior (median 38.38%) to following ART (26.86%). We observed significant selection for proviruses with defects on major spliced donor/packaging signal (MSD/PSI) (33.33% prior to 84.44% on ART) and gag (40% to 75%) but against proviruses with defects on env (66.67% to 21.25%) (p-values: 0.001-0.006). However, Rev-response elements (RRE) remained very conserved during ART; a median (interquartile range) of 0 (0-5.8%) proviruses carried RRE defects. Patterns of gag defects mainly involved start codon or deletion while deletion was the only defect pattern on env. HLA-associated mutations emerged or significantly shifted in env of 5/11 participants, but these mutations did not cause changes in the predicted MHC binding affinity or immunogenicity. Significant changes in predicted bNAbs sensitivity were observed for env of 2/11 participants.
Conclusions:
NFL defective proviruses are subjected to significant differential selection pressures on MSD/PSI, gag and env under ART. Gag defects are likely linked to deletions on MSD/PSI suggesting the selection for proviruses with impaired replication and infectivity. Selection against deletions on env is possibly linked to HLA escape mechanism but did not lead to significant changes in MHC binding or immunogenicity suggesting the possible involvement of other immune and viral factors.