Abstract Body

Background: Rates of first-line treatment failure and switches to second-line therapy are key indicators of national antiretroviral therapy (ART) programmes, but there is little consensus on the immunological failure (IF) criteria to be used in the absence of virological monitoring, which remains too expensive for most African national programmes.

Methods: Using routinely-collected data from the Tanzanian HIV programme, we compared IF rates using the criteria of WHO 2010, 2013 and Tanzania 2005, 2009 guidelines (with confirmatory CD4 counts). We included adults initiating ART in 2004-2011 with a pre-treatment CD4 count and ≥6 months of follow-up. For the WHO-2010 definition, we assessed sub- hazard ratios (SHRs) for IF and subsequent switch to second-line therapy, using competing risks methods to account for deaths.

Results: Among 121,308 adults, 6,108 (5.0%) to 19,380 (16.0%) persons experienced IF depending on the definition (Table). The cumulative probability of IF by 6 years ranged from 13.0% (12.5,13.4) under the WHO-2013 definition to 40.6% (39.8,41.5) under the WHO-2010-unconfirmed definition. Lower IF rates mean persons spending longer on first-line therapy and therefore higher death rates on first-line treatment, with a cumulative probability of death by 6 years of 5.3% (4.9,5.6) under the WHO-2013 definition versus 3.7% (3.4,3.9) under the WHO-2010-unconfirmed definition. IF predictors included ART initiation in dispensaries versus hospitals, being male, lower current weight and lower current CD4 count. Of 7,382 participants in the time-to-switch analysis, 416 (6%) switched, while 355 (5%) died before switching. Four years after IF, the cumulative probability of switching was 7.3% (6.6,8.0) and of death 6.8% (6.0,7.6). Those who immunologically-failed in dispensaries, health centres and government facilities were least likely to switch.

Conclusions: IF rates and unmet need for second-line therapy are high in Tanzania, regardless of the IF definition. We recommend use of confirmatory CD4 counts to avoid unnecessary switching, despite the resulting slightly higher mortality. Clarification of the guidelines and virological monitoring, at least for persons with IF, is recommended. Lower-level government health facilities need more support to reduce treatment failure rates and improve uptake of second-line therapy, if the benefits of improved coverage through decentralisation are to be sustained.

viewer?TAG_ACTION=SECURE_FILE_DOWNLOAD&V
Immunological failure definitions and rates.