Background: Targeted sequencing technologies using primer IDs can result in more accurate representations of HIV-1 populations but PCR bias and recombination have hampered progress. Here we describe a new method for library construction that produces a larger number of tagged consensus sequences, increases sensitivity of haplotype determination, and reveals the sources of recombination.
Methods: Each molecule of cDNA from mixtures of varying percentages of wild-type and mutant HIV-1 pol transcripts containing 14 drug resistance mutations was tagged uniquely using a gene-specific primer with primer IDs. cDNAs were then PCR amplified using two methods: (1) 90mer primers containing required MiSeq sequences; (2) 22mer primers containing uracil followed by digestion, cleavage and ligation to linkers containing MiSeq sequences. DNA was sequenced using paired-end MiSeq Illumina technology and consensus sequences were derived from a super-majority (≥80% consensus) for each unique ID. Consensus sequences were analyzed for PCR bias, errors, recombination, and sensitivity for detecting haplotypes.
Results: Of the total cDNA molecules used as template, amplified cDNA with unique tags ranged from 3-19% for method 1 and from 15-52% for method 2. The average error rates for method 1 and 2 were 9.3×10-5 and 1.4×10-4, respectively, both comparable to RT error rates. The PCR recombination rate for method 1 was 0.16% but only 0.01% for method 2. Method 1 was able to detect drug resistance mutations down to 0.01% and method 2 down to 0.001%. The sensitivity of haplotype detection was better for method 2: for samples containing 10% or 1% mutant, method 1 never detected linkage of all 14 mutations, whereas method 2 detected all 14 33-35% of the time. Method 2 always detected linkage of the 8 mutations nearest the 3′ end of the amplicon suggesting that PCR recombination is due to incomplete cDNA synthesis.
Conclusions: A linker ligation method of amplifying tagged cDNA reduced both PCR bias and recombination rate compared to standard methods, and was superior at detecting haplotypes within 200bp of the 3′ end of the template. However, it correctly detected linkage across the entire 570bp amplicon in only 1/3 of sequences, suggesting that cDNA synthesis is typically incomplete leading to PCR recombination and thus limiting sensitivity for detection of linked mutations. Improved methods are needed for cDNA synthesis to increase the reliability of haplotype determination for HIV-1 populations.