Abstract Body

Ensuring correct HIV test results are given to participants is critical for both large field-based prevention trials and national HIV-testing programs. During the Botswana Combination Prevention Project (BCPP), a cluster randomized trial designed to evaluate the impact of a combination prevention package on population level HIV incidence in Botswana, robust quality assurance (QA) measures have been implemented to ensure lay counselors deliver accurate test results in the field.

BCPP conducted home-based and mobile HIV testing campaigns in 15 intervention communities from October 2013-February 2016. Lay counselors (130) were trained to conduct rapid HIV testing and point of care PIMA CD4 testing with annual refresher training, weekly internal Quality Control (QC) panel testing, and proficiency testing (PT) 3 times/year. In the first community, 100% of field samples were retested in the reference laboratory using EIA HIV testing. In subsequent communities a random sample of 5-10% of samples were retested. Laboratory based PIMA CD4 counts were repeated on samples from 155 field PIMA CD4 counts. Monthly supervision and monitoring visits were conducted.

Weekly QC panels conducted on 1000 positive and 975 negative HIV tests in the field using Determine and First Response assays produced 100% accurate results. Overall, 89% of counselors achieved a pass on PT increasing from 78% at baseline to 96% and 97% in the final two rounds. Repeat EIA testing of 3002 DBS samples demonstrated a 99.6% agreement between field and laboratory HIV-test results, with a kappa score of 0.99, p < 0.0001. Of the 12 discordant results, 4 were false negative and 8 were false positive in field-testing. The overall pass rate for PIMA CD4 PT was 89% (81%, 93%, 95%, and 88% rounds 1-4). Levels of agreement between field and lab PIMA CD4 results are shown in figure 1, with a mean difference of 16.7 cells/µL (95% CI -10 – 43). At the CD4 threshold of 350 there was 86% agreement (21 of 155 misclassified).

With a strong training, monitoring, and QA program, BCPP lay counselors conducted HIV-testing in field settings accurately and to a high standard. This indicates that lay counselors can competently and correctly implement HIV testing at scale in field settings, and gives very high confidence in BCPP HIV-test results. Concordance between PIMA CD4 field results and lab results were within expected ranges.