Background:
Identifying traits of HIV-1 Envelope (Env) linked with broadly neutralizing antibody (bnAb) development is critical for designing bnAb vaccines. Here we report a rare twin cysteine (Cys) motif in the variable loop 1 (V1) region that is enriched among Env of bnAb inducers.
Methods:
V1 Cys insertions were functionally characterized in vitro and quantified in Env sequence datasets from bnAb inducer cohorts (Swiss 4.5K), longitudinal cohorts (ZPHI, SHCS, CAPRISA) and the LANL sequence database. Factors associated with frequency of V1 Cys insertions were analyzed using logistic regression.
Results:
Studying Env from 35 bnAb inducers from the Swiss 4.5K screen we noted a high overall neutralization resistance and observed a rare twin Cys motif in V1 in several Envs. Functional studies with bnAb inducer Envs and analysis of the CATNAP database showed that Envs with the V1 Cys motif had a modestly increased neutralization resistance pointing towards a compensatory stabilizing effect. Analyzing Env sequences from 1,105 Swiss 4.5K participants, we observed an independent association with neutralization where >20% of elite neutralizers carried the motif compared to 5% of non-neutralizers. Sequence simulations and comparison to >6000 Env sequences of the LANL database showed that the observed frequency of Env with two extra Cys in V1 is unlikely to occur by chance. Twin V1 Cys occur in recent transmission, suggesting no transmission bias, and show peak frequencies in later infection. Longitudinal Env profiles of 57 CAPRISA donors showed fluctuating frequencies of variants with extra V1 Cys, suggesting the motif alone provides a limited fitness advantage. Notably, a high proportion of Env with twin V1 Cys was transmitted in the AMP trial placebo arms (15% and 9% of participants in HVTN703 and 704, respectively) while breakthrough viruses showed a VRC01 treatment dose dependent reduction in twin V1 Cys, suggesting a fitness deficit of transmitted twin V1 Cys viruses.
Conclusions:
Our data support a role of the V1 Cys motif in optimizing V1 stabilization and epitope shielding during neutralization escape. Gains in neutralization resistance and viral fitness through the motif may vary depending on the extent of virus nAb co-evolution. BnAb-experienced viruses are likely optimized for both fitness and resistance, while recently escaped variants may, despite twin V1 Cys insertions, still have fitness deficits and are rapidly counter-selected when new pressure arises as in the case of VRC01 prophylaxis.