Background
In ART-suppressed PWH, HIV transcription is variably blocked at the stages of elongation, completion, and splicing. Few studies have measured CA-HIV RNA in elite controllers (EC), and these have been limited to detection of unspliced HIV RNA. We hypothesized that EC would differ from ART-suppressed noncontrollers (NC) in the blocks to various stages of HIV transcription, and that ART would reduce completed and spliced HIV RNA in EC.
Methods
Levels of sequential HIV transcripts and their corresponding HIV DNA regions were measured by ddPCR in blood CD4+ T cells obtained longitudinally from 10 EC before ART and up to 3-5 years on ART. HIV levels were compared between EC and 34 NC who started ART in chronic infection. ART duration did not differ between groups.
Results
Before ART, EC showed more initiated than 5’ elongated HIV RNA (median ratio 0.13; P=0.0039), and more elongated than Pol (P=0.002) or completed HIV RNA (P=0.016). Completed and multiply spliced HIV RNA were only detected in 3/10 and 4/10 EC, respectively. Compared to treated NC, untreated EC had lower levels of LTR-pre-Gag and Pol HIV DNA (P≤0.033); fewer 3’ defective (P=0.054) but not 5’ defective or intact proviruses; lower levels of initiated (P=0.0045) and completed HIV RNA (P=0.017); higher levels of initiated HIV RNA/DNA (P=0.0002) and 5’ elongated HIV RNA/DNA (P<0.0001); and a lower ratio of completed/elongated RNA (P=0.047). ART treatment of EC led to increases in CD4+ T cell counts (median change: 70 cells/µl; P=0.03); decreases in all HIV DNA regions (all P≤0.031); decreases in defective (P=0.0078, 0.016) and intact proviruses (P=0.031); decreases in initiated (P=0.020) and 5’ elongated HIV RNA (P=0.014); and a decrease in the ratio of elongated/initiated HIV RNA (P=0.049). Multiply spliced HIV RNA became undetectable in all EC. Compared to treated NC, treated EC had lower levels of multiply spliced HIV RNA (P<0.0001), paradoxically higher levels of initiated HIV RNA/DNA (P<0.0001), and lower ratios of completed/elongated (P=0.037) and multiply spliced/completed HIV RNA (P=0.025).
Conclusions
Compared to ART, natural control of HIV led to fewer infected cells (particularly those with LTR and Psi DNA), paradoxically higher levels per provirus of short HIV transcripts, and lower proportions of completed and spliced HIV transcripts. ART treatment of controllers reduced HIV reservoirs, decreased HIV transcripts, and increased CD4+ T cell counts, suggesting ART may improve health and should be offered to EC.