Background
The majority of proviral DNA sequences are defective due to deletions and mutations in open reading frames. Defects in non-coding regions can also render proviruses defective; such proviruses may appear structurally intact yet potentially lack full competence. In this study, we identified such defective proviruses in two participants followed for 30 years and used them as genetic barcodes to study the dynamics and lineage relationships of CD4+ T cell subsets.
Methods
Two participants with chronic HIV-1 infection who initiated their first antiretroviral therapy (ART) regimen in 1992-1994 (pre-HAART era) were studied. Full-length HIV-1 sequencing was performed on sorted naïve, central memory, and effector memory CD4+ T cell subsets with longitudinal follow-up from 2008 to 2025. Expanded clones of structurally intact proviruses with defects in the 5’ leader region were used as genetic barcodes to follow the transition of CD4+ T cells among naïve, central memory and effector memory pools. ART drug-resistance mutations (DRMs) served as temporal markers to estimate when the pool of defective proviruses was seeded.
Results
In the two participants reported, several structurally intact HIV-1 proviruses contained 5’ leader defects and represented clonal expansions that accounted for 14% (148/1038 in Pt1) and 17% (211/1269 in Pt2) of proviral sequences. These HIV-1 proviruses were detected across all three CD4+ T cell subsets, including naïve CD4+ T cells. DRM-based temporal markers traced these proviruses back to early NRTI mono/dual therapy in the mid-1990s. Bidirectional migration between naïve and memory subsets was consistently observed in both participants. Some clones were noted to persist for at least 13 years, defining a long-lived reservoir of CD4+ T cells.
Conclusions
The combined use of proviral genetic barcoding and DRM-based analysis provides a framework for defining the kinetics of distinct HIV-1 provirus pools and, by extension, discrete elements of the CD4+ T cell pool. Novel structurally intact proviruses were found to expand and persist during ART without evidence of significant viremia. Given the recent reports that such genomes may be able to generate virus-like particles, these intact but noninfectious genomes represent a distinct and understudied element of HIV-1 infection that may contribute to long-term persistence and add to the pool of biologically active “defective” HIV-1 proviruses. Together, these insights refine our understanding of HIV-1 pathogenesis.