Abstract Body

Background

 HIV-1 exceptional elite controllers (EECs) represent a model of functional cure, able to sustain undetectable viremia and prevent disease progression for decades without therapy. After 35 years of follow-up, we describe two EECs who lost viral control (transient controllers, T-EEC) and compare them with two persistent controllers (P-EEC) who maintained long-term remission. These cases provide a unique opportunity to elucidate mechanisms underlying durable spontaneous control.

Methods

We performed a longitudinal immuno-virological analysis on available samples. We measured reservoir integrity by intact proviral DNA assay and near full-length individual proviral sequencing and examined viral quasispecies evolution and infectivity/fusogenicity of Env clones. We also evaluated HIV-antibodies titers, heterologous/autologous neutralization capacity, HIV-1–specific T-cell responses and markers of T cell exhaustion.

Results

 All four EEC (2 females and 2 males) maintained undetectable viremia for at least 32 years. P-EEC maintained durable control for 35 and 37 years while T-EEC showed persistent viremia (>50 copies/mL) after 32 years. P-EECs carried protective alleles (B57:01/B14:02 and B27:05/B58:01, respectively), whereas T-EEC lacked them (B14:B51 and B39:01/B44:02). P-EECs exhibited a reservoir predominantly composed of defective genomes (>90%), low proviral load and highly homogeneous viral quasispecies with ancestral sequences. P-EEC showed limited neutralization capacity and low antibody titers over time. High polyfunctional Gag-specific T-cell response remained stable across of follow-up with no T-cell escape mutations. The results are consistent with absent viral replication throughout follow-up. Prior losing control, T-EECs displayed an increase in reservoir size and viral quasispecies diversity. They developed autologous neutralizing responses; compensated by the emergence of new variants with higher functionality and ability to escape immune recognition. At the same time, T-EECs also showed low magnitude and polyfunctionality of Gag-specific T-cell response alongside heightened T-cell activation and proliferation compared to P-EEC.

Conclusions

These findings suggest that host genetic factors, immune response and reservoir dynamics are critical determinants of long-term spontaneous HIV-1 control. Long-term follow-up revealed that EECs are a heterogeneous group. Distinguishing among both phenotypes is crucial for understanding durable remission and guiding functional cure strategies