Background
In 2021, U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention expanded recommendations for rectal and pharyngeal screening for chlamydia and gonorrhea among sexual and gender minorities, adolescents and young adults. Offering self-collection improves extragenital testing uptake. However, no extragenital assays have been FDA-approved for self-collection, hindering implementation. To overcome this regulatory barrier in a low-resource area with high sexually transmitted infection (STI) and HIV transmission, a state health department, urban clinic and university collaborated to enable extragenital self-collection via a state Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendment.
Methods
We compared state lab results of self-collected (SC) to provider-collected (PC) extragenital specimens from patients >14 years old with STI risk seen by a physician or nurse practitioner in the low-resource community clinic setting. Verbal and visual patient instructions were provided. Informed by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research, we evaluated barriers, facilitators and effectiveness of the validation study. Acceptability and feasibility were assessed via a clinic staff focus group and paired SC and PC specimens were compared using Cohen’s kappa and McNemar tests.
Results
From July to September 2024, patients (N = 293, mean 34.0 years old, 66.9% Black) provided 133 rectal and 177 pharyngeal paired specimens. Although patients’ mistrust of research emerged as a barrier, incentives and organizational coordination were identified as key facilitators of study feasibility, acceptability and specimen collection fidelity. Results demonstrated 96.9-100% agreement and statistical comparability between SC and PC specimens by site and infection type. Discrepancies were more often positive on SC than PC, and more frequently occurred at the rectum compared to the pharynx.
Conclusions
Consistent with prior studies, results suggest a trend toward detecting more extragenital infections via self-collection than provider-collection. Findings highlight considerations for implementing self-collection in low-resource settings. Patients’ willingness to undergo testing by self-sampling at specific sites of sexual penetration expands opportunities for STI detection and treatment. In the face of reduced federal support for sexual health services, strategic coordination among state and local organizations to scale up extragenital self-testing may help decrease STI and subsequent HIV transmission in resource-scarce areas.