Abstract Body

Plasma HIV-1 RNA above the limit of detection of commercial assays on ART arise from i)complete cycles of viral replication as a consequence of inadequate drug exposure and/or drug resistance; or from ii)virions produced from proviruses in clonally-expanded cells without complete cycles of replication. Most proviruses that persist on ART are defective, including those hypermutated by APOBEC. Although hypermutated proviruses can be transcribed into mRNA and even spliced, their packaging into virions is expected to be very inefficient. Here we report the first instance of false virologic failure on ART arising from cells with hypermutated proviruses.

A 46 year old female presented with detectable HIV on ART ranging from 439 to 4230 copies/mL. Single genome sequencing (SGS) analysis (p6-Pro-RT) of 4 longitudinal plasma samples obtained over 13 months was performed. To characterize the source of viremia, fractions of plasma after low- (2700 g) and high-speed centrifugation (17 200 g) and total nucleic acid from PBMC were analyzed by SGS including cell-associated HIV mRNA and near-full length (NFL) sequencing of proviral DNA.

SGS (p6-Pro-RT) revealed multiple, identical hypermutated sequences in all low-and one high-speed plasma pellet(s), and in PBMC HIV DNA (p6-Pro-RT and NFL) and cell-associated HIV mRNA (Figure). The only non-hypermutated sequences were from the high-speed plasma pellet (4 of 4) and PBMC HIV DNA (1 of 10) at the 13 month time point. Sequencing of gag revealed a stop codon at amino acid 211 which would prevent capsid (p24) formation.

This is the first report of false virologic failure of ART resulting from release of defective HIV nucleic acid into plasma. The source appears to be a large population of cells with identical hypermutated proviruses, i.e. an infected CD4+ T-cell clone that is undergoing cytolysis and release of cellular nucleic acid including HIV DNA and mRNA into plasma. Production of viral proteins and packaging of viral genomes is a highly unlikely source given the hypermutated genome with at least one stop codon in gag-p24.  Release of cellular nucleic acids into plasma may be an underappreciated cause of false virologic failure.