Scaling up PrEP is a priority in ending the HIV epidemic plans, yet progress remains inequitable. Indicators are needed to drive PrEP programming, guide resource allocation, and quantify inequities. We developed a PrEP equity index (PEI) to support local target development for PrEP coverage among MSM, focusing on racial equity.
To calculate the PEI, we first estimated PrEP coverage using a PrEP-to-need ratio, where the numerator was prevalence of PrEP use in the past 6-months (derived either from the Sexual Health Survey (SHS) among NYC MSM aged 18-40, 2018, or the National HIV Behavioral Surveillance (NHBS) study among NYC MSM, 2017) and the denominator was epidemiologic need (derived either from HIV diagnosis rate per 100,000 for men ages 13-59 from NYC HIV surveillance data and US Census data, or the number of new diagnoses among MSM, both for 2017), each stratified by race/ethnicity (Black, Latino, White). We then calculated the PEI by dividing the PrEP coverage for white MSM by that for Black and Latino MSM. To set targets for Black and Latino MSM, we then multiplied the PEI by the PrEP use prevalence for each group, effectively quantifying the improvement in PrEP coverage needed to approximate the PrEP coverage of White MSM (with a maximum of 100%).
PrEP use prevalence was 40% and 31% using SHS 2018 and NHBS 2017, respectively, and neither set of estimates differed significantly by race/ethnicity. Numbers of new HIV diagnoses for Black, Latino, and White MSM were 396, 515, and 234, respectively; HIV diagnosis rates for Black, Latino, and White men ages 13-59 were 105, 77, and 31/100,000, respectively. PEI varied markedly for Black and Latino MSM regardless of approach used (Black MSM: 1.7-3.9; Latino MSM: 2.3-3.3). Targets for Black MSM (range: 59%-100%) and Latino MSM (range: 77%-100%) varied by approach used to define PEI (figure), but would require substantial increases in current PrEP use prevalence to be met (Black MSM: 65-295% increase; Latino MSM: 131-235% increase).
Applying a newly developed equity index to set local PrEP targets dramatically illustrates inequity in PrEP coverage for Black and Latino MSM, likely driven by both inequities in PrEP access and the large differential HIV burden in these populations. These findings illustrate the distance needed to travel to move beyond equality towards equity and should motivate intensive efforts to address racial disparities in PrEP scale-up.