Accurate measures of HCV incidence are needed for surveillance and prevention efforts. Acute HCV infection is a stage of recent infection (virologically+ but IgG antibody[Ab]-), but the duration of this state may vary depending on the assays used. We compared the duration of acute HCV infection before seroconversion as defined by various assay algorithms, and examined their impact on the precision of biomarker-based incidence estimation.
Retrospective analysis of data from HCV seroconversion panels of initially uninfected individuals, sampled at a median of 5-day intervals (SeraCare and Zeptometrix), was used estimate the mean duration of acute HCV infection (the average duration between infection and Ab seroconversion). To estimate the date of infection, HCV uninfected individuals were assayed by nucleic acid testing (NAT) for HCV RNA detection and/or by the Abbott Murex HCV Ag/Ab Combo Assay. The estimated date of HCV IgG Ab seroconversion was monitored by various serologic assays. Using days before seroconversion as the unit of analysis, the mean duration of acute HCV infection was calculated using binomial regression with a logit cubic functional form and a maximum likelihood approach.
The range in the mean duration of acute infection was 20 to 35 days depending on the assay used to identify initial infection and IgG Ab seroconversion (Table 1). NAT testing resulted in longer estimated period of acute infection than using the Ag/Ab Combo Assay by approximately 6-9 days (Table 1). Although there is a loss in the mean duration of acute infection by using the Ag/Ab Combo Assay, this did not meaningfully affect sample size considerations for precise incidence estimation in many hypothetical contexts. To achieve a relative standard error of 20% for an expected incidence estimate of 20%, a survey of 1700 individuals would be required for the largest estimated interval of acute infection from these data (35 days). To achieve the same precision with a 20 day acute interval (smallest interval), the survey size would need to be increased to 4400.
Efforts to optimize biomarker-based methods to estimate the population-level incidence of HCV infection may yield a sensitive and powerful tool to actively monitor the progress toward the WHO’s goal of HCV elimination by 2030. Employing acute screening in cross-sectional testing algorithms would extend the window period of identifying a ‘recent’ infection, but this will be dependent on the combination of assays used.