HIV rapid diagnostic test (RDT) kit manufacturers require that reactive bands observed in the test area of the kit are reported as positive regardless of intensity of coloration. Some studies have suggested that weakly reactive RDT results should not be considered positive except in blood donor screening. However, a reliable estimate of the proportion of weakly reactive bands in 3rd generation HIV RDT’s that would actually be false positive has not been published. We assessed the percentage of weakly reactive bands that were subsequently confirmed negative by HIV DNA-PCR.
Over an 11 year period (2002 to 2013) we determined the proportion of inconclusive results that were later confirmed negative by DNA PCR. Inconclusive results were based on the observance of a weakly reactive band on at least one of three 3rd generation HIV RDT kits used within a sequential testing algorithm. The three kits were Alere Determine, Chembio Stat-Pak, and Uni-Gold. The algorithm was as follows; all tests were initially run on Determine. If negative, reported as negative; if positive they were confirmed with Stat Pak. If discrepant, Uni-Gold was used as a tie breaker. HIV-1 DNA PCR Roche Amplicor Version 1.5 was used as the confirmatory test method.
39,294(12.9%) of 303,010 individuals screened for HIV were positive. 468 (0.15%) of the same initially had inconclusive HIV RDT results. The HIV status of the 468 individuals was resolved by HIV-1 Western Blot (17), HIV-RNA PCR (14), or HIV-DNA PCR (437) confirmatory tests. 224 of the 437 cases confirmed by DNA-PCR RDT’s were independently repeated by another tech to control for individual variability. Only these 224 cases were included in this analysis. Of these 224 cases, 148 (66.1%) were negative by HIV DNA PCR. Of note, repeating the 224 tests gave a total of 448 instances of testing with both Determine and Sat-Pak RDT kits, and 441 testing instances with Uni-Gold kit. (Detailed results Table attached).
The majority of weakly reactive RDT results from all three kits used turned out to be negative on confirmatory HIV DNA PCR testing. This is contrary to manufacturers’ instructions to interpret all such tests as positive. Our results also lend credence to previously published calls for testing algorithms to refer weakly reactive RDT test results for confirmatory testing. This is especially pertinent in the era of ART initiation based solely on HIV RDT results and scaled-up HIV surveillance programs in resource limited settings.