Background: Prior research has demonstrated that visuospatial functioning is often deleteriously affected in HIV-Associated Neurocognitive Disorders (HAND). Nevertheless, tests of visuospatial abilities are often omitted in current HAND research. We sought to determine whether the addition of visuospatial measures to an established HIV neuropsychological battery would increase the rate of HAND diagnoses. Additionally, to determine the relative likelihood that visuospatial functioning is impaired in HAND, we compared the rate of deficit on a visuospatial test to that of other tests in an established battery.
Methods: Seventy HIV-seropositive (69 currently on ART) and 11 healthy control participants completed neuropsychological testing as part of a NIH Intramural HIV screening protocol (NCT01875588). Participants were administered the Benton Judgment of Line Orientation (JLO), a test of visuospatial abilities, as well as the CHARTER battery, an established HAND battery assessing attention, executive function, information processing, motor speed, verbal fluency, and memory.
Results: Using the CHARTER battery alone, 21.4% (15/70) of patients met criteria for HAND. However, with the addition of a visuospatial measure, HAND prevalence rose to 30% (21/70), an 8.6% increase. The rate of deficient performance on JLO in HIV patients was one of the highest observed (25.7%), fourth to PASAT, a measure of attention (28.6%), BVMT (a visual memory test) total recall (28.6%) and BVMT delayed recall (30%), with the average rate of individuals with deficient performance across all tests being 16% (see Table). Mean T-scores were significantly lower in patients than controls for the PASAT (t=2.1, p=0.04), BVMT total recall (t=2.25, p=0.03), BVMT delayed recall (t= 2.19, p=0.03), and JLO (t=3.26, p=0.004), but not on the other 11 of 14 CHARTER measures.
Conclusions: Our preliminary data suggest that visuospatial functioning may be a commonly affected cognitive domain in HIV patients in the HAART era. The omission of visuospatial measures on established HAND batteries may lead to an incomplete understanding of the neuropsychological impairments associated with HIV, as well as to possibly underestimating HAND prevalence. Future research should consider evaluating visuospatial functioning in addition to the other commonly assessed cognitive domains.