Background: The size of the latent reservoir in a patient with ART induced HIV suppression can be estimated by viral outgrowth in a limiting dilution culture of CD4+ T cells under activating conditions with exogenous cells and IL-2. A culture well containing HIV is typically detected with p24 ELISA, but recently HIV RNA RT-PCR has been shown to be more sensitive. This allowed us to determine the proportion of cells producing viral RNA that resulted in replication competent virus.
Methods: Resting memory CD4+ T cells from 9 virally suppressed patients were stimulated with beads coated with antibodies against CD2, CD3, and CD28, and plated in limiting dilution in two conditions: 1) 100,000 MOLT-4/CCR5 cells per well and IL-2 were added on day 1 to facilitate viral outgrowth, or 2) the reverse-transcriptase inhibitor efavirenz (EFV) was present immediately on day 0 to suppress viral replication, with no exogenous cells or IL-2 added. Culture media was collected and replaced every 4 days, and the viral RNA was isolated using a paramagnetic nanoparticle based method. Real time HIV gag RT-PCR was performed and the frequency of HIV RNA producing cells was calculated using the R package for Extreme Limiting Dilution Analysis.
Results: The frequency of HIV RNA producing cells following latency disruption was strongly correlated under viral outgrowth vs. viral suppression conditions. In most positive wells under viral suppression, viral RNA was detectable by day 4; some were followed by an increase while others decreased. In some outgrowth wells, the amount of HIV RNA on days 8 and 12 greatly exceeded that in comparable wells in the suppression assay. Culture supernatant from each positive outgrowth well was used to infect new cultures of activated but uninfected allogeneic CD4+ T cells. 33 of the 78 (42%) original positive outgrowth wells contained culture-confirmed replication competent virus, with significant well-to-well and patient-to-patient variability in the amount of virus produced.
Conclusions: While HIV gag RNA RT-PCR with a concentrated viral suppression culture was as sensitive for quantifying the frequency of HIV RNA producing cells as a viral outgrowth assay, much HIV RNA recovered in the outgrowth wells, including many wells that had increasing amounts of viral RNA over time, did not represent replication-competent virus.