Background: The international epidemic of hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is in its second decade among HIV-infected men who have sex with men (MSM) but little is known about mechanisms of transmission. Our prior case control study in New York City found unprotected receptive anal intercourse as the main risk factor for acquisition, but studies in England and Germany suggest that group sex or anal trauma are the main risk factors. We sought to understand whether significant disruption of the anorectum is required for HCV acquisition among HIV-infected MSM. Methodology: We used single genome sequencing (SGS) to identify and enumerate transmitted HCV genomes to test the hypothesis that sexual transmission would be associated with few transmitted genomes, parenteral infection through injection would be associated with many, and bloody or traumatic sex would be associated with an intermediate number of transmitted genomes. Detailed sex and drug histories and plasma were obtained during acute HCV infection in HIV-infected MSM. Results: Eight men with acute HCV underwent SGS of their plasma virus RNA from the earliest available visits. All had precise and unambiguous identification and enumeration of transmitted HCV genomes. Six of 8 men were productively infected by single HCV genomes; none had rectal bleeding associated with sex nor were they exposed to blood of others; one had injected methamphetamine but without sharing injection equipment, and then had sex. Two men were infected by >10 genomes; one had shared injection equipment and then had sex, and the other denied any injection, rectal trauma, or bleeding with sex. None had an intermediate number of infecting genomes. Conclusions: Most HCV infections of HIV-infected men were caused by a single transmitted virus, suggesting that HCV infection of MSM is due to a limited exposure to infecting virus across a relatively intact mucosal barrier. In contrast, the one man who had shared injection equipment was infected by a high number of viruses. These patterns of HCV infection parallel both sexual and parenteral acquisition of HIV, where most infections are caused by a single versus a higher number of transmitted HIV genomes, respectively. Larger prospective risk factor studies are needed using SGS to provide novel epidemiological insights to better characterize HCV acquisition in HIV-infected MSM.